Lost Password? No account yet? Register
  • Narrow screen resolution
  • Wide screen resolution
  • Auto width resolution
  • Increase font size
  • Decrease font size
  • Default font size
  • default color
  • red color
  • green color

New Kosova Report

Tuesday
Jan 06th
Nationalism and State Creation: The Kosovar Case PDF Print E-mail
Sunday, 03 February 2008

New Kosova Report
Arlind V. Bytyqi
For many countries worldwide, nationalism - as we have come to know today, has led to the formation of entities known as states. These have been bloody struggles, and due to their just nature, they have enabled certain ethnicities to file for self-determination.

Typology of nationalism, however, is quite diverse. In some cases, nationalist movements have been born recently, whereas in some others, such feelings of belonging have been there for a long time. In Kosovo, nationalism has always played a major role, and one can freely say it has been one of the top elements that has aided the Kosovar cause towards independence.

Under Former Yugoslavia, Albanians have consistently been identified as pariahs, due to their ethnic difference from other constituent republics. This difference - Albanianism - has been successfully maintained throughout years, and has relentlessly triggered tension and feelings of anti-Albanian existence among the state runners of the then Yugoslav state. At the same time, it has been an ensuring factor to the Albanian population of Kosovo that one day, nationalism will serve their purpose for self-rule.

Ethno nationalism has at all times been a distinctive feature of the Albanians inside the Yugoslav ‘state-pool’. The arguer claiming that Yugoslavia was a country where everyone lived peacefully and in harmony, is challenged to face up to my statement: this state, in the first place, was built on wrong premises. Formation of a nation-state has a number of particularistic elements attached to it; and these more than often are a commonality of all the people living there. To begin with, all national groups that were part of Yugoslavia shared different histories. This was especially true for the Albanians. There was absolutely nothing that tied them together historically speaking with any other nationality, except for confrontation and tension. Then, language was another element, alongside with values and traditions. Albanian language and traditions are extremely different from languages and traditions of other ethnic groups which were part of Yugoslavia. Therefore, we are dealing here with various national identities, thus, Kosovo Albanians have always been a unique case.

Ethnic nationalism, for Kosovo Albanians, suggested that they were a nation which shared same values and one culture. These values and culture were not artificial. They were carried onto Albanians by their forerunners, and this is a strong element identifying a nation. In the same vein, they ensured for legitimacy by different international factors. The behavior of Kosovo Albanians throughout these times was characterized by a persistent effort to safeguard their national identity, as well as their long struggle for self-determination. Whilst the former was effectively preserved, the latter required commitment and sacrifices. Kosovo Albanians were not after self-rule under Yugoslavian regime, which was then coined autonomy. They were after full independence/statehood where no other state would interfere in internal and foreign affairs.

In this regard, since national identity never posed a problem for Kosovo Albanians in terms of defense from external factors, their nationalist movement was shifted and took the form of a state-centric nationalism. This suggested their struggle for statehood, given they had all other prerequisites for it.

There obviously is a difference between a state and a nation. Even though these two phrases are often used as one (nation-states) they advocate two different institutions. Kosovo was always a place of a nation, but it was unfortunately never a state. And this is where the sharp distinction should be kept in mind: the Kosovar state is not being born in an artificial manner. On the contrary, we are facing nothing but the merging process of the two concepts, nation and state, into one. Nationalists worldwide claim that if a populace can identify in terms of language, traditions, culture and values, the next logical step to be taken is proclamation of statehood. Kosovo Albanians are filing for their right to self-governance; governance over their own people.
   
In essence, among Kosovo Albanians, we find a number of other ethnic groups or minorities living there presently. Fundamentally, and in theory, this goes against the formula for the creation of a state based on premises of a unique language, same traditions and so on. Nevertheless, Kosovo is not after an ethnically clean state. In this world of the twenty-first century where globalization and amalgamation of all kinds of civilizations and national groups in all parts of the world takes place on daily basis, pure nation-states is an ideal which will never be reached.

Since creation of the Kosovar state is now a reality, it is pivotal that there is a unified or mass acknowledgement of the state. In other words, the state should be viewed as legitimate by the people inside its territory. A special emphasis here is put on the Serb minority, who should by all means embrace the Kosovar state, for it is their state, too.  

When nationalism is used to describe the Kosovo Albanians’ efforts for self-determination, we should be cagey to draw the attention to the typology of nationalism that was employed. Whilst in many regions of the world, extremist nationalist movements have been used to achieve certain goals, Kosovo Albanians have pursued a rather different path. Their way was one of patience and preservation of who they are. Thus, if we were to give another prefix to nationalism based on the Kosovar case, that would be coined either ‘persistent nationalism’ or ‘serene nationalism’.
   
The trick with this type of nationalism is that is requires a long-term pledge. Alongside the pledge, you also have to agree to the wretched fact that there will be carnage by the authority that you are rejecting as your ruler. For Kosovo Albanians it took a very long time, perhaps, more than it should have taken. It also cost them hundreds and thousands of lives and destruction of properties. Another factor which is by no means to be neglected, especially if we are talking about a small country, as is Kosovo, is the support by ‘the big guys’. It is always better if this comes in time, as it would save a nation from a lot of despair and suffering.

Having the strength of mind and bravery to rise against all forms of oppression and attempts to squash an entire nation, is the key to a successful campaign which will deliver the fundamental right: self-determination. Kosovo Albanians have lived through and possessed both, and today they are at a decisive moment of their long-lasting struggle. This struggle in its superlative sense is pure nationalism. It is nationalism understood within the framework of a modern connotation of the word, with all its positive aspects following behind.

By This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it

Comments (2)add comment

Jeremy said:

0
...
We Read this article in school. we are studying it right now and i just thought i would like to say that it is a good article but seems to have some bias, and have a little bit of perspective giving precedance over another. Other then that i would say that this is a very good topic and article.
 
September 30, 2008
Votes: +0

ardiana said:

0
...
great article, I enjoyed reading it
 
April 10, 2008
Votes: +0

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
< Prev   Next >

Members






Lost Password?
No account yet? Register

Support us!

Support us!

 

Signup for our newsletter!

Newsletter




Quick Vote

Should Kosovo stick with EULEX , or ask for a new mission ?
 

advertisement



Columns

Blackbird
Image The same old song There are a few things I like to talk about when we drink.  Like everyone, I like to gossip a...
Vetėvendosje!
Image Review of Vetevendosje activities in 2008 Opposing EULEX The year began with opposition to EULEX on the basis that this new international ...
Henry H. Perritt
Image Kosovo government is right to resist pressure The Government of Kosovo is right to resist the “Six-point plan,” which nullifies the ...
Arlind V. Bytyqi
Image A questionable authority Uncertain over their own mandate, with nuances of ridiculousness resulting from their behavior of a ...