| Kosovo, an "EU State" |
|
|
|
| By: Drilon Gashi, New York, U.S.A. | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
| Wednesday, 23 April 2008 | |||||||||||||||||||||||||
![]() Drilon Gashi
The term refers to the creation of the state, which began with NATO military intervention in 1999 aimed at bombing Serbian military targets and halting the crackdown and ethnic cleansing by Serbian forces on Kosovar Albanian civilians.
However besides NATO’s current presence as a security force in Kosovo, the country’s recently established constitution containing the Ahtisaari Plan, allows for it in actuality to represent a unique “EU state”. This is not to say that Kosovo is a member of the EU, rather just a country representing the values and guidelines included within the EU framework. (Hence an EU state, not an “EU member state”) The European Union allows for its member states to maintain their national character and culture while at the same time loosely identifying themselves as “Europeans”. The same exists in Kosovo, where approximately 95% of the population is Albanian, 3% Serbian, yet the overarching term that all inhabitants of Kosovo could identify with is Kosovar. Many of the specifics of this Kosovar identity, and the rights included for all Kosovars are included within the Constitution of Kosovo. Usually the majority population in a country is very reluctant to compromise, especially with a sensitive topic such as national identity. So then, how could Kosovar Albanians concede their right to identify simply as Albanian; the answer is that this was a necessary and sufficient condition to ensure their internationally recognized independence. The Serbian minority on the other hand has rights which in some instances go beyond those of other minorities and even the Albanian majority. Certainly, the Albanians in Southern Serbia do not enjoy the same rights as their Serbian counterparts in Kosovo. If all of Kosovo’s inhabitants are not accepting of this “independence plan”, can it work, or will it “fail” and will Kosovo not be able to resemble an EU state? Albert Rohan, former deputy UN mediator for the Kosovo status recently stated that “if Serbs continue refusing to cooperate, a great deal of the Ahtisaari plan, particularly decentralization, will be impossible to implement.” Let us not however confuse this topic with that of Kosovo’s independence, as Kosovo’s sovereignty is definite and irreversible, trust this because it is coming from someone not lobbying for votes in Serbia’s upcoming elections. For the independence plan to work however, Serbian inhabitants of Kosovo must realize what is most beneficial to them. Kosovo offers them special rights guaranteed by the constitution, a guaranteed 10 seats in Parliament reserved for Serbian representatives as well as national characters and symbols which aren’t inherently Albanian and therefore cannot in any way be identified as discriminatory. In fact, these neutral symbols may be most discriminatory and not representative for the Albanian majority itself. Kosovo has been offered modern, Western European solutions to the age-old rivalry between Albanians and Serbians which was best characterized by the continuous persecution of Kosovar Albanians. The best option for the Serbs would be to accept their citizenship as Kosovars because all nationalistic propaganda aside, Belgrade will not be particularly inviting for these Serbs in the long run. A debate is going on in Kosovo on whether the country should have compromised so much towards the Ahtisaari plan if the prime beneficiaries have not themselves been welcoming of it? Well, the hope is that Kosovo’s Serbs will soon realize what they could compromise by ignoring this internationally sponsored UN plan. This realization will ensure that Kosovo will bring to life the constitution she recently adopted and truly exhibit an EU state. Therefore foreign minister Sergei Lavrov was quite wrong when he stated recently that Kosovo has divided Europe. Instead Kosovo will really test whether Europeans are united in buying into the multi-ethnic or “European” identity they themselves have been pushing for, a question sensitive for several member nations and a compromise being realized in Kosovo. The democratic, and inherently slow processes, which are going on around the world towards recognizing Kosovo’s independence should realize Kosovo’s sui generis case and its legitimate existence as a sovereign, multi-ethnic, and EU state.
Set as favorite
Bookmark
Email This
Comments (10)
![]()
Valentina
said:
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
Igor: Wake up. Its over. The independence of Kosova is a fact, get over the typical Serbian way of considering the albanians “terrorists”. People are getting a bit tierd of this kind of arguments, chance strategy, do something else, just stop using the same talks as always – kind of boring an dmakes it even harder to take you seriously. There is no more need for you (or anybody else serb or other) to try and talk about the "discrimination " of serbs in Kosova or by the way “rights” at all. Where were you like 9 years ago when children (albanians of course) were burned and slaughtered alive???? Didn’t you have books so that you could learn about human rights then? And now you are telling me how many serbs there are in Kosova (and not even that fact correct given, it has never been 7% serbs living in Kosova - get your facts right). It is amazing and yet frustrating to hear a serb talk about human rights in terms that makes me wonder how on earth the definition of human rights is understood by persons like you Igor. When I hear Igor talk about rights of serbs (obviously having no clue what kind of treatment (beneficial or not) the serb minority in Kosova has, make me recognize that this fellow doesn’t even know what he’s talking about. Have you even been in Kosova at all or is your life all about “watching the Serbian television and get incorrect input”?) I can’t help comparing the way your reasoning like the one in China due to the population of Tibet: The talks about human rights goes on but in reality the prevention of human rights is of no value/importance what so ever. You involve the value of EU, but to understand that you have to begin with understanding the value of humanity. So, my advice to you Igor is that you try to, first of all educate your self in the kosovar system and find out the reality concerning rights of the minorities, (in this way you might get your numbers right and you would not feel like the website is anti-serb. This website is actually in a spirit of anti-violence, its about going forth and integrate to the rest of the civilisation, that actually is beyond the “great” SERBIA, so called EU). Second, you should be more concerned about reconciliation than the “Kosovar identity” – You can’t talk about something that you don’t understand. The assumption that there is no such as “Kosovar identity “ was one of the main serb mistakes that made the war of 1998 in Kosova possible, so please learn from history instead of fighting for something that is of zero importance. You don’t get anywhere by denying identities, especially national identities, Hitler didn’t, Stalin didn’t, Slobodan didn’t….got the point? Drilon, all respect to you for presenting the reality of Kosova and Kosovars as it is. And you are very right assuming the country as an EU state. And soon enough it will be a independent, multi-ethnic and sovereign EU member state. |
|
|
report abuse
vote down
vote up
|
| Why would it be "created by Serbia's rulers and their followers". That's a conspiracy theory I've never heard before especially given that the Serbian government would firmly be against this and even organised protests against the declaration. There are many problems with the independence declaration - including the fact that it pleases nobody and fails to give a coherent account of what Kosovo's status actually is - but this is not one of them. | |
|
report abuse
vote down
vote up
|
| A NATO state, or a state created by Serbia's rulers and their followers? | |
|
report abuse
vote down
vote up
|
|
"Barbed wire to keep the Serbs in"? That's a pretty hateful and disgusting thing to say. |
|
|
report abuse
vote down
vote up
|
|
Igor, “Grow a brain!” you are right, but you will have to lead. Because, All my figures come from the Serbian Government not the CIA fact book, so if you consider the Serbian Government not creditable. The only figure I used from the fact book is YOUR 7% and total population!!!! “There were no standards achieved before this FALSE status, the minorities in the Serbian PROVINCE of Kosovo are not respected live in the enclaves, surrounded by the barb wire, with no food, no power, no jobs, no freedom of movement of respected human rights, with the constant fear for their life.” The FALSE State gives more right in their constitution, to Serb minorities, than any county in the World gave to their minorities. Only if Serbia treated it minorities with ½ that of Kosovo, minorities in Serbia would be dancing for JOY!!! The Serb enclaves are barb wired to kept the Serb in so they won’t hurt the non-Serb population. “With no food, no power, no jobs, no freedom of movement of respected human rights, with the constant fear for their life.” This, sounds like the unlucky Albanians who live in the north. “How much is the human life worth?” To normal people, it priceless, To a Serb its not worth a bullet shell as we seen in Croatia, Bosnia, and in Kosovo. “Why would the Hague release Haradinaj when they know that a lot of witnesses were murdered in order not to be witnesses, and suspend the claim that Carla Del Ponte (Hague prosecutor) wrote in her book, that hundreds of young Serbs were killed and their organs removed? There is something really wrong here”. If you read Serbian new papers you would know three of the five prosecutors did not wont to prosecute Haradinaj because they did not have enough evidents and the Serbian Government did not cooperate with the Hague. So Haradinaj did not do anything wrong. And Carla Del Ponte book, the organs being removed from Serbs was put in the book by Del Ponte co-author so they can sell more books!!! Igor, I am grad that we see eye to eye on all your points and known we can Grow a brain together!!! |
|
|
report abuse
vote down
vote up
|
|
Igor, You yourself should do some research before posting a comment!!! According to the Serbian Government the census from 1991, Kosova had a total of 194,190 Serbs, and that was a downward trend from 1981, where there were more the 230,000. In 2004 Kosovo Government estimated that there would have been a total of 165,000 Kosova Serbs in Kosova with that trend. Known according to CIA Fact Book your 7% Serb population. There are some 148,870(7% * 2,126,708) Serbs currently living in Kosovo.” If you take the 1991 census of 194,190 less the current figure of 148,870, I get a total figure of 48,320 Serbs exodus!!!! That is fare less than your half, and most of them left because of their participation with what Milosevic did. They Terrorized the Albanians living in Kosovo, so that means those Serbs that left Kosovo are the TRUE TERRORISTS from your comment!!! |
|
|
report abuse
vote down
vote up
|
| < Prev | Next > |
|---|
New Kosova Report
Putting news on Kosovo / Kosova in perspective. Analyzing trends, major developments and less talked about aspects of Kosovo.
Kosovars are running away from risk
Ten years after thousands of young Kosovar Albanians risked their lives to fight against Slobodan ...
A Sunday in Kosovo
We woke up early and drove to the Danish camp. On Sundays the mess served brunch. There were waffl...
Kosovo is more like Georgia, not S. Ossetia
Lazy journalists, couch geopolitical strategists, and Cold War nostalgists have all been convinced ...
Justice with an ethnic flavor
In an interview regarding the opening of a new negotiation process between Belgrade and Prishtina ...