Lost Password? No account yet? Register
  • Narrow screen resolution
  • Wide screen resolution
  • Auto width resolution
  • Increase font size
  • Decrease font size
  • Default font size
  • default color
  • red color
  • green color

New Kosova Report

Thursday
Jan 08th
Which way now for Kosovo? PDF Print E-mail
By Kreshnik Hoxha   
Tuesday, 16 September 2008
Which way now for Kosovo?
Which way now for Kosovo?
The activities that institutions of Republic of Kosovo and of Republic of Serbia seem not to have the guts to undertake neither in Prishtina nor in Belgrade and not even in the aristocratic atmospheres sealed with diplomacy in the lavish hotels of Vienna,
are being done by random citizens of the two neighbouring countries, precisely where the conflict was conceived – a place that has produced more history than it could be consumed and digested regionally – Kosovo and Serbia.

A face to face meeting between Kosovar and Serbian representatives in the presence of regional and European representatives with regards to discussions relating to the events and experiences from the last war in Kosovo; truth finding and establishment of the Truth Commission; was organised by NGO INTEGRA in cooperation with IKV Pax Christi of Holland in the premises of Hotel Victory on 12th of September – far away from the aristocratic atmospheres and palatable dinners served to the leaders of both countries.

‘Truth Finding – Which way now for Kosovo?’ is the roundtable organised as the final phase of the empirical research about the ‘Attitudes towards inter-ethnic relations and truth telling’. This event was attended by members of civil societies from Holland, Belgium and Bosnia and Herzegovina. The sequence which captured everyone’s interest was the presence of public figures from political, judicial and cultural segments of Kosovo, who were eager to learn the formula on what on earth managed to convince Albanians and Serbs to discuss and face the truths of the war in Kosovo, while the leaders of two countries dig major holes to avoid these kind of meetings.

The truth of a conflict between two ethnic groups is an abstract and rather relative concept, which is prone to diametrically opposite interpretations of the parties involved in the conflict, who although cohabit in a common place, they share different values, beliefs and judgements regarding the past with its open wounds. The vacuum created from the freezing of interactions between these parties serves as an advantage for those who want to exploit the absence of these interactions in order to precipitate unpleasant situations where interethnic hatred serves as the key mineral that fosters this post-war society. However, these kind of initiatives (such as the one undertaken by INTEGRA) aiming to amalgamate the opposite interpretations in order to enable analysis and evaluations of the past between the two ethic groups are the most efficient mechanisms for bringing reconciliation and mutual respect between parties and should not be seen as adding salt to an open wound.

Visiting the newborn capital, that occupied the world media as well as the Serb ones last February, Belgradians seemed to be analysing the common interests with their Kosovar counterparts as far as the past is concerned; and they were trying to take the situation into a different dimension by exploring various avenues for cooperation in the future. Fully persuaded that truth finding and inter-ethnic reconciliation are the fundamentals of respect and empathy under the EU umbrella, the Kosovar representatives (including associations of war victims and NGOs) were agreeing that Serb as well as Kosovar nationalist propagandas ought to be buried in a sterile ground and further concentrate on the consolidation of the Truth Commission. The presence of the head of the Humanitarian Law Centre, Miss Natasa Kandic, a figure adored and hated in equal measure by the people of Balkans, fuelled the heat of the debate. The discussion reached its pinnacle when Miss Kandic began to share the experiences of truth telling from the other wars in the former Yugoslavia as well as suggesting techniques on how to tackle this issue professionally.

This NGO-INTEGRA-led research comprised of 73% Albanians, 24.9% Serbs and 1.3% included other communities in Kosovo, namely Bosniaks, Goranis, Romas and Ashakalis. Asked about the root of the problem between two ethnic groups in Kosovo, Albanians respondents pointed their finger towards Belgrade and it’s interference in Kosovo as well as the lack of interest among Serbs to integrate in the Kosovar society, claiming that these factors are the embryo of the problem, whereas the Serbs castigate the attitude of the Kosovar leaders and the lack of Albanian efforts for Kosovo Serb integration. There is a significant difference when the sources of history regarding the past are analysed. Looked from the Albanian and Serb prisms, the main sources are media (28.6%) and (48.8%), respectively, whereas family conversations (23.4%) and (3.4%) and finally books make up 31.6% and 21%, respectively. It is very evident that creation of opinions and ideas regarding the Kosovo war among Albanians is mainly based on family conversations, something which is not quite the case with Serbs.

The research teaches us an interesting fact that both parties of the Kosovo conflict support the idea of sharing their experiences to each other. However, only a small number of respondents were comfortable with actively taking part themselves.

Judged from the point of view of Albanian respondents, the main culprit that led to the Kosovo war is the Serb nation (78%), whereas according to Serb respondents the Albanian nation who need to get the blame (64.9%).

A somewhat compelling result arises when the credibility of the International Crime Tribunal for the former Yugoslavia (ICTY) is analysed. Not surprisingly 99.5% of Serbs respondents did not agree with the statement that ‘ICTY is doing a great work in discovering the truth and punishing individuals who have committed crimes during the war in Kosovo”, whereas among Albanians 22.7% agreed with the statement, 22% are neutral, 44.3% do not agree and 9.7% have no opinion.

The respondents were asked to give an estimate on how long it will take for the normalisation of relations between Serbs and Albanians and a clear scepticism is observed among the two parties as far as this issue is concerned. 28% claimed that the relations will never normalise, 30.9% claimed that it will take 3 – 10 years, whereas 32.9% said they don’t know. Only 5.3% demonstrated optimism stating that normalisation of relations will occur relatively soon within 1 or 2 years.

The results of the research brought together as a by-product the recommendations of the two working groups, where a specific focus was dedicated to the belief that the establishment of the Truth Commission will further deepen the efforts of truth telling. Now, it remains to see to what extent Serbs will integrate in Kosovo’s life, whether they will choose to live under the motto ‘I love my enclave’ and promote their freedom of movement from one enclave to another; it also remains to see whether Albanians will continue to scribble and erase Serbian words in official documents and whether they will continue to listen to Bijelo Dugme fearing that they might be overheard from their neighbours in their flat. 

Finally, remains to see what will happen with Genc, Dejan, Hana, Zorica – will they fight in front of internationals or will they pretend to be best mates?
Comments (13)add comment

Nexhat Domi said:

0
...
Do not talk history Dragan! Since the beginning Albanians to mention the story when you get an ill. All know that Albanians come from the Illyrer, making Albanians in the first place in Balkan!
Serbs have done cruel things in Kosova as murder torture rape ETC. The Serbs lost Kosovo.
Kosova is proud Nation today. Serbians need's to join.
 
September 24, 2008
Votes: +1

ROOT said:

0
...
Well said Sarah,

actually, both sides need to make alternations in their history curricula as both of them are exhausted with ideological and nationalist propaganda.

While agreeing completely with Sad Clown, I still think these initiatives will be helpful in introducing reconciliation between Serbs and Albanians. But, it is going to take a long time before a compromise is achieved.
 
September 20, 2008
Votes: +1

Sarah Franco said:

0
...
Dragana,

you must be joking!!!

Most serbs don't even know that Kosova was conquered in the Balkan Wars (1912).

and the students educated since 1990 learned the history that fitted the ideology of milosevic and kostunica, no wonder you had so many young boys and girls looting the shops in Belgrade and shouting that they wanted to kill albanians, while they were stealing from their co-citizens as a sign of grief for the loss of the heart of the nation.

as a person who closely follow this problem of the use of history for idelogical purposes in serbian education system: "they forget the content but keep the ideology"

fortunately, there are projects such as this one:

http://www.cdsee.org/jhp/index.html

but its implementation in Serbia has been facing lots of obstacles. let's hope something changes now that serbia has a pro-european government.



 
September 20, 2008
Votes: +2

ROOT said:

0
...
Dragana,

maybe you desperately need to get involved in such initiatives to wash the propaganda which is feeding your brain!

Albanians might not read as much, but the Serbs who read more than Albanians are still extremely prejudiced!


 
September 20, 2008
Votes: +1

dragana said:

0
...
"It is very evident that creation of opinions and ideas regarding the Kosovo war among Albanians is mainly based on family conversations, something which is not quite the case with Serbs."

Of course not, that's beacuse Serbians actually learned history which was not the case for the albanians in Kosovo, sad to say. Unfortunatle, education (especially for women) is not something of priority for albanians. Their main goals are to hate serbs, drive them out of kosovo and have about 15 children which they cant afford to feed or educate.

 
September 19, 2008
Votes: -2

Sarah Franco said:

0
...
sad clown, believe me, I share your frustration...
 
September 19, 2008
Votes: +1

Sad clown said:

71
...
Sarah,

Your perceptions are on the money. A minor detail was missing, among donors in Kosovo, a conference is not worth its salt unless its held in the resort town of Ohrid, Macedonia. From my own observations, the farther away a conference is from the root of the problem, the more useless it is. Never mind the money.

Now, what would have been a better way to do all this? I would have put Ms Natasa Kandic on TV on prime time. She is widely respected among Albanians for her human rights credentials and TV has the widest penetration in Kosova.

Don't run another poll just to find out that "Albanians and Serbs don't get along," but find out if there are any regional opportunities or potential approaches that have opened up since the last poll. Above all, I want to see recommendations. Actionable advice you have gotten since your same study... umm, let's say two weeks ago.
 
September 19, 2008
Votes: +3

Sarah Franco said:

0
...
sad clown,
there is a pertinent point in what you are saying.

for some people indeed the NGO iniciatives have become a business, a 'market niche'. I have met some of those 'professionals', and it is disgusting to see that there isn't a serious emotional commitment.

the same apply for the millions of euros spent in conferences, workshops, etc, etc, etc.

I often feel very frustrated to see so much money being wasted and so many people misusing it to promote themselves... including people who in the past had an honourable behaviour but meanwhile let themselves become corrupted as it became easier to get funding for activities like this one.

yes, that money would be much better spent in building houses and giving incentives for new jobs to be created.

the problem is that there is no way you are going to convince those who have money and power to make a difference unless you pressure them.

I am thinking specifically of the EU and western donor, for instance.

how can you influence decision makers?

by pressuring them.

how do you pressure them?

by keeping some 'umconfortable issues' on the agenda.

that includes organizing workshops, conferences, meetings, publications, etc.

it's how the game is played.

you have a lot of parasitism, especially now that there are no serious risks for those who get involved in this game;

you have a lot of people who think they know best and are ready to lecture the 'backwards balkanics' that 'getting along' is solely dependent on a act of will by the average citizens, thus indirectly putting the blame on them;

you have a lot of people that just want to go to a conference in sarajevo because it's a kind of tourism, or, even better, in the adriatic coast...

but you also have very committed people, who engage out of a sense of duty and not for personal interest or to buy their good conscience.

those are the people that matter, but in order to influence decision makers, these people need to be visible, and event like this are a good way to make them visible, so that then they may pressure for real change, which will only be possible if political leaders fell pressured.

 
September 18, 2008
Votes: +2

Owen said:

91
...
Sad Clown, you're right, the present and the future demand attention, but unless the the past is dealt with the wounds fester.
 
September 18, 2008
Votes: +0

Sad clown said:

71
...
This reminds me of O.J. Simpson asking "Why can't we all get along?" This is racist towards the two ethnic groups, a waste of money by the European donors and enrichment by the Albanian-Serb NGOs.

It makes all these people feel good about themselves while achieving absolutely nothing.

Instead of treating the root causes of the situation, which is largely political and economic, they deal with the symptoms. Instead of spending the money where the impact would be greater, they deal with what sells among donors. The magic formula to get money from foreign donors in Kosovo today is to get a Gypsy and a Serb on board and talk about world peace and other lousy things like that.
 
September 18, 2008
Votes: +2

Owen said:

91
...
Very interesting - and encouraging - article. I hope you'll keep us informed about the progress of the initiative. How far it is successful is a matter of relevance that goes far beyond the borders of Kosova and Serbia, or Former Yugoslavia.
 
September 18, 2008
Votes: +0

Sarah Franco said:

0
...
very interesting article.

it's crucial that citizens from kosova and serbia start contacting each other, as well as kosovar serbs and kosovar albanians.

however, real change in inter-ethnic relations will come only when the governments of kosova and from serbia take the initiative to normalize inter-state relations.

for now this depends on serbia. the first step would be dismantling the parallel institutions set up in the north and stop undermining the economy of kosova by stop allowing the north controlled by serbs to be a haven for smugglers.

still, if normal citizens keep having this kind of initiatives, it will work as a pressure for their respective governments.

regarding reconciliation, we have to always bear in mind that the truth is not reached by creating a blend of each group's respective 'truths'. I am always very afraid of the word reconciliation, because usually that is the approach taken, and this basically corresponds to the popular idea that 'all sides were guilty'.
 
September 17, 2008
Votes: +2

Icezero said:

0
...
I am very happy New Kosova Report started publishing articles which call for reconciliation. I strongly believe that only reconciliation and respect to each other can bring us closer to a common goal, EU membership.

If British and French, German and Poles, Spanish and Dutch can live together, I don't see why Serbians, Albanians, Goranis, Turks, Bosniaks and Romas cannot live together in Kosovo and Serbia.

Only by listening to each other we can prosper.

Fight and hate will just prolong our disorientation.

There is always a space for compromise...


 
September 16, 2008
Votes: +3

Write comment
smaller | bigger

security image
Write the displayed characters


busy
 
Next >

Translate article



Members






Lost Password?
No account yet? Register

Support us!

Support us!

 

Signup for our newsletter!

Newsletter




Quick Vote

Have you or do you plan to go skiing in Kosovo this Winter?
 

advertisement



Columns

Blackbird
Image United nations I said, “Surely the world is getting better.” She frowned and began listing the rea...
Vetėvendosje!
Image Review of Vetevendosje activities in 2008 Opposing EULEX The year began with opposition to EULEX on the basis that this new international ...
Henry H. Perritt
Image Kosovo government is right to resist pressure The Government of Kosovo is right to resist the “Six-point plan,” which nullifies the ...
Arlind V. Bytyqi
Image A questionable authority Uncertain over their own mandate, with nuances of ridiculousness resulting from their behavior of a ...